Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Karol Mikula ( karol.mikula@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Valeria Tomaselli
© 2025 Aneta A. Ožvat, Mária Šibíková, Jozef Šibík, Jakub Sigmund, Juraj Papčo, Michal Kollár, Karol Mikula.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Ožvat AA, Šibíková M, Šibík J, Sigmund J, Papčo J, Kollár M, Mikula K (2025) Wetland classification and revitalisation monitoring by using drone data. Vegetation Ecology and Diversity 62: e175765. https://doi.org/10.3897/ved.175765
|
Wetlands are essential ecosystems increasingly threatened by human activities and climate change. This study presents a method for classifying and monitoring wetland habitats in the Čiližská Radvaň protected area (Slovak Republic) using RGB drone imagery and the Natural Numerical Network (NatNet), a mathematically based supervised deep learning approach. The primary aim was to evaluate the effectiveness of NatNet in identifying target habitat types and to assess the impact of ongoing revitalisation efforts. Habitat types were classified using RGB drone imagery and ground-truth training polygons that represented the dominant vegetation communities in Čiližská Radvaň wetland. The NatNet achieved the training classification success rate exceeding 97%, allowing the creation of relevancy maps successfully identifying spatial habitat distribution. Relevancy maps verified in the field reached classification accuracy of 0.88 and F1 score of 0.90 across all habitats together. Results showed observable shifts in habitat extent and structure after one year of restoration, confirming the suitability of the method for detecting ecological changes in wetland environments.
Drone imagery, habitat revitalisation monitoring, Natural Numerical Networks (NatNet), remote sensing, supervised deep learning, wetland habitat classification
Wetlands, defined as areas where the land is saturated or inundated with water and is occupied by plants adapted to water-saturated conditions (
In Central Europe, during the 20th century, the melioration scheme with the aim of turning the area into agricultural land changed the lowland landscape dramatically. Artificial channels were built to drain the area, and traditional landscape management activities as grazing and mowing of wet meadows were replaced by intensive agriculture. Similarly, in the studied wetland – Čiližská Radvaň, where water regime degradation (decrease of groundwater table, absence of seasonal floodings), together with land-use changes, resulted in a high level of invasion of the degraded wetland habitats. The invasion of non-native plant species is considered as one of the major threats to the natural habitats (
Scientific research has highlighted the importance of wetland restoration in combating biodiversity loss and maintaining ecosystem services (
Traditional field-based monitoring is often time-consuming and limited in spatial and temporal extent. The use of remote-sensing techniques in the case of wetland monitoring provides a very promising technique that allows inundation mapping of large areas (
The main aims of the present study are: (1) to evaluate the use of the Natural Numerical Network for the automatic identification of wetland habitats from RGB drone imagery, and (2) to assess the success of revitalization by analysing changes in habitat extent between 2023 and 2024 in a recently restored wetland.
Čiližské močiare protected area, is part of the Natura 2000 network (site code: SKUEV0227). It is located in Central Europe, Pannonian region, Slovak Republic, in the Podunajská nížina Lowland (Fig.
In the recent past, the majority of the locality was covered by wet meadows (previous agricultural land was abandoned due to very low productivity), invaded by Solidago gigantea and Aster lanceolatus plant species, together with the expansive grass Calamagrostis canescens. The most humid parts hosted wetland habitats, the reed bed (Phragmition communis Koch 1926) with an admixture of Carex spp. and Juncus spp. species, as well as Lythrum salicaria and Lycopus europaeus in the lower herb layer. Recent restoration activities include improvement of the water regime by using the existing floodgate situated on the old melioration channel, and regular mowing.
The historical situation of this area is depicted in Fig.
A. The locality Čiližská Radvaň wetland, in the Slovak Republic. The area of interest is marked by the red square. B. The 19th century wetland in the locality of Čiližská Radvaň segmented on the historical map of the Second military survey (1819–1869), and C. its transformation in an orthophoto image (2017–2019).
For our analysis, we used drone images captured on November 2nd 2023, and October 17th 2024. They provided sufficient distinction between habitat types and thus formed the basis for our classification algorithm and for creating the optimal Natural Numerical Network for this wetland area of interest. For both flights, we used DJI Air2S drone with Sensor dimension 1-inch CMOS, Resolution 20 MP (for photos), Field of View (FOV) 88°, Focal Length Equivalent 22 mm, Aperture f/2.8. Both flights were performed from 10:00 to 12:00 am the flight planner was Dronelink with parameters flight height 100 m, maximal flight speed 13 m/s, and area covered 72300 m2. The Ground Sampling Distance (GSD) was 2.91 cm/pixel. The image overlaps for both flights and are reported in Suppl. material
Global navigation systems (GNSS) technologies were used to reference the ortophotomosaic in the spatial reference coordinate system. The Control points measured by the GNSS technique served directly for the transformation of photogrammetric models/ortophotomosaic into a reference system. In Suppl. material
The vegetation height was calculated by measuring differences between the digital surface model (DSM) captured with the drone and the digital terrain model (DTM), obtained from the nationwide aerial laser scanning from the years 2017–2019, which was provided by the Geodesy, Cartography and Cadastre Authority of the Slovak Republic. Only the ground class was used, from which a raster 20 cm × 20 cm was created by using kriging interpolation. In Suppl. material
Several key workflow steps were performed in the NaturaSat software (
Processed drone data and field habitat information were first imported into NaturaSat. Software tools for image filtering and automatic and semi-automatic segmentations were applied to delineate polygons for the selected habitats. Within these polygons, representative squares were created, and their statistics were calculated using the software monitoring tools to construct the feature space used for NatNet training. NatNet training and classification, as well as the computation of relevancy maps, were performed using the classification tools in NaturaSat (see section “NatNet classification methodology for drone images”). Furthermore, the NaturaSat Historical Maps Transformation service was used to identify corresponding areas of interest between historical maps and the contemporary interactive map (see section “Geographic and historical context”). The subsequent workflow steps related to validation, analysis of habitat changes, and their ecological interpretation are discussed in the “Results and Discussion” section.
We utilised RGB drone imagery to classify wetland habitats based on their spectral characteristics. The drone images, captured over multiple dates, were composed of red, green, and blue (RGB) channels resampled to 20 cm pixel resolution. Due to seasonal variations in vegetation and environmental conditions, the winter and spring images were excluded as they were unsuitable for classification. As a result, the autumn imagery from November 2023 and October 2024 (Fig.
To delineate the habitats, polygons were constructed by NaturaSat automatic and semi-automatic segmentation tool using the November 2023 drone data, and they were validated using GPS tracks obtained in the field (Fig.
For the classification process, a training dataset was constructed from the polygons. Representative squares of the size 11 × 11 pixels were selected manually from each polygon to serve as training samples (Fig.
The Natural Numerical Network (NatNet) was used for classification. It is a supervised deep learning classification algorithm designed for applications like habitat identification, particularly in environmental monitoring, such as the Natura 2000 protected areas (
The basic mechanism of the Natural Numerical Network can be described as follows: the forward diffusion causes the movement of points belonging to one cluster of the training set toward each other, and the opposite effect, keeping the points away from each other for different clusters of the training set, is caused by the backward diffusion. The NatNet contains a few parameters that are optimised in the training phase of the method. The training (optimization of parameters) of the NatNet yields the optimal dynamics of the training set vertices, i.e., the trained Natural Numerical Network. Then, by the trained network, a new observation is classified. In our case, the classification of all image pixels outside the training dataset is performed, and the relevancy map for each habitat is computed with the goal of habitat extent identification. Since the relevancy maps assign classification relevancy levels to different pixels (regions), it is also crucial in analysing degraded or transitional habitats.
The training process of the Natural Numerical Network is performed on the labelled input data, where representative squares in the imagery can be characterized by their statistical and differential values across multiple optical bands, such as mean, maximum, minimum, standard deviation, and graph-Laplacian (see also
After successful training, each pixel of the drone image is classified by the optimal NatNet, the relevancy of its classification is computed by formulas (3) and (4) in the Suppl. material
A. Drone imagery of Čiližská Radvaň (Slovak Republic) wetland from November 2023; B. drone imagery of Čiližská Radvaň wetland from November 2023 with representative squares inside the polygons of Typha angustifolia (green polygons), Typha-Phragmites (blue polygon), and Phragmites australis (red polygons) and C. drone imagery from October 2024.
The dynamics of the NatNet for the learning dataset with one unlabelled point (green circle) after the dimension reduction by Principal Component Analysis. Purple, blue, and yellow points represent the points from the analysed habitats, while red and pink points are the representative squares from “background“ clusters.
The first objective of this study was to train the Natural Numerical Network for the classification and identification of wetland habitats in the Čiližská Radvaň area, in the Sloval Republic. Three distinct wetland habitats were selected for the study, each represented by 30 representative squares. These training squares ensure comprehensive coverage of the spectral variability in each habitat cluster, thereby enhancing the model’s ability to distinguish between different habitat types. The training phase of the NatNet resulted in a high classification accuracy, achieving a success rate of 97.34%. This level of accuracy means that the algorithm was able to correctly classify most of the data points, with only four misclassified points. Notably, misclassifications occurred between the Typha angustifolia and Typha-Phragmites habitats, as well as between the Typha-Phragmites and Phragmites australis habitats. These habitats share dominant species, and the differences are mainly in the proportion of species covered. These misclassifications likely reflect overlapping characteristics of vegetation in ecotonal areas where spectral similarities disable the algorithm to find sharp distinctions.
Despite the existence of these few misclassified points, the overall success rate of 97.34% is considered sufficient for NatNet to be applied to habitat classification. The success rate was obtained with the set of parameters where K1 = 3800, K2 = 4300, and δ = 0.002 (see also the Suppl. material
In the Čiližská Radvaň wetland, the major vegetation type is Phragmition communis (Lk11 – reed beds) with two associations, Phragmitetum vulgaris and Typhetum angustifoliae and transitional parts where Phragmites australis and Typha angustifolia occur together. Typha, as well as Phragmites species, are highly characteristic for wetland environments due to their ability to thrive in waterlogged soils and shallow waters. The robust root system of Typha helps in sediment trapping and nutrient cycling, making it a vital component of wetland ecosystems. Fig.
The pure Phragmites habitat in the Čiližská Radvaň wetland is a relatively rare habitat, with only a few locations identified. It occurs mainly along the water channel, on places with the highest water levels in the wetland. It occurs in shallow water and along the edges of bodies of water, contributing to the ecological health of the wetland. Despite this limited presence, the relevancy map for the Phragmites habitat effectively captures these areas, even identifying some regions that were not initially segmented (Fig.
In our study, the Typha-Phragmites dominated habitat is a specific one due to its unique composition, representing a mixture of Typha angustifolia and Phragmites australis, two species commonly associated with wetland ecosystems. This mixed habitat is situated along the old channel, and also in broader surroundings, where the ecological conditions support both species (Fig.
The relevancy map for the Typha-dominated habitat (Fig.
The spectral characteristics of the Typha habitat exhibit similarities to those of the invasive species in the surrounding area, which leads to the tendency of the spectral model to overestimate Typha relevancy, highlighting the need to refine the approach. Nevertheless, a notable distinction is observed in the height of the canopy, which can thus be used as a differentiating factor. Thus, we incorporated additional structural information such as vegetation height. It was calculated using the difference of DSM and DTM models (Suppl. material
An estimated threshold value was determined for the minimum height of the Typha canopy, and this information was combined with the relevancy map in Fig.
The second aim of our work was to compare the extent of wetland habitats after approximately one year since the initial monitoring. To accomplish a comparative analysis for the assessment of the ecological changes and evaluate the impact of restoration and management efforts on the wetland over one year, we leveraged high-resolution drone imagery collected in October 2024, along with detailed habitat relevancy maps generated from this imagery (Fig.
To validate these relevancy maps, a systematic approach was applied using randomly generated points in the high-relevancy (white colour) as well as in low-relevancy (black colour) areas of the map for each habitat. Field surveys were then conducted to assess the accuracy of these classifications. During the field work on November 2nd 2024, 58 validation points randomly generated in high and low relevancy areas were checked, and 7 of them were found to be inaccurate. Table
The study of the wetland habitats using relevancy maps resulting from NatNet classification is an effective tool for monitoring changes in habitat extent. We were able to observe a shift in vegetation type occurrence after one year of revitalisation activities, which could be hardly possible by using only field research and permanent plots. In Fig.
A quantitative comparison of the 2023 and 2024 relevancy maps indicates apparent shifts in vegetation types (Table
Table
Both dominant species profit from higher water levels in the locality after revitalization, which is also visible from the expansion of the Typha–Phragmites habitat in the central part of the wetland, where this community is slowly replacing areas dominated by Calamagrostis epigeios and invasive species. Typha angustifolia (and association Typhetum angustifoliae) prefers more stable waterlogged conditions (
Part of drone imagery of Čiližská Radvaň (Slovak Republic) wetland from November 2023 and October 2024 with training polygons and relevancy maps for A, B. Phragmites habitat; C, D. Typha-Phragmites habitat; E, F. Typha habitat, and G, H. Typha habitat combined with information about vegetation height.
Results of the validation process for relevancy maps by randomly generated points. Confusion matrices, Accuracy, Precision, Recall, and F1 scores are presented for all three target habitats separately.
| Predicted habitat type | Accuracy | Precision | Recall | F1 score | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typha | Not Typha | ||||||
| Actual habitat type | Typha | 14 | 0 | 0.89 | 0.82 | 1 | 0.90 |
| Not Typha | 3 | 10 | |||||
| Typha-Phragmites | Not Typha-Phragmites | ||||||
| Typha-Phragmites | 9 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | |
| Not Typha-Phragmites | 0 | 6 | |||||
| Phragmites | Not Phragmites | ||||||
| Phragmites | 7 | 0 | 0.75 | 0.64 | 1 | 0.78 | |
| Not Phragmites | 4 | 5 | |||||
Results of the validation process for relevancy maps by randomly generated points. Confusion matrix, Accuracy, Precision, Recall, and F1 scores is presented for wetland habitats in common.
| Predicted | Accuracy | Precision | Recall | F1 score | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Habitat | Not Habitat | ||||||
| Actual | Habitat | 30 | 0 | 0.88 | 0.81 | 1 | 0.90 |
| Not Habitat | 7 | 21 | |||||
Our results provide spatially explicit evidence that revitalisation measures, particularly hydrological improvements and recurrent mowing, have facilitated an increase of Typha–Phragmites and Phragmites-dominated vegetation and that the drone–NatNet workflow reliably captures these changes. We confirmed that the relevancy map approach not only delineates existing habitat boundaries but also supports quantitative, year-to-year monitoring of wetland restoration outcomes.
Although the study focuses on a single area, namely the Čiližská Radvaň wetland in the Slovak Republic, and on one year of monitoring, this concentrated approach allowed for a detailed evaluation of habitat dynamics during the early phase of restoration. The area of the wetland is not large-scale, but for the purposes of revitalization monitoring we found the extent suitable, since the restoration process is challenging and is usually spatially limited to smaller areas. One year of monitoring can capture initial stages of vegetation change after revitalisation, and these trends could be different in the next years, depending on the continuous succession and other factors. Our results cannot predict the wetland development in the future, but can serve as a methodological basis for the next monitoring since we proved the possibility to identify single vegetation associations and shifts between them.
While the limited spatial and temporal extent naturally constrains broader generalisation, our study provides a solid and well-documented baseline for future multi-year and multi-site comparisons. Described methods could be transferred to other wetlands with similar habitats; however, local phenology must be considered when choosing the dates for drone data sampling.
All authors were involved in conceptualization and study design and methodology creation. K. Mikula led the project and M. Šibíková co-led the project. K.Mikula and A.A. Ožvat designed the NatNet classification algorithm for drone data, A.A. Ožvat and M. Kollár implemented NatNet in NaturaSat software and K. Mikula, A.A. Ožvat and M. Kollár performed all data analyses in NaturaSat software. M. Šibíková and J. Šibík were responsible for field sampling, GPS measurements, and field validation. J. Papčo and J. Sigmund were responsible for drone flights and drone data processing. All authors participated on the interpretation of results, text writing, and preparation of Figures.
This work was supported by ESA contract 4000140486/23/NL/SC/rp “Monitoring of Slovakian wetlands with links to the Black Sea and Danube Regional Initiative”, and by grants APVV-23-0186, APVV-22-0151, VV-MVP-24-0116, VEGA 1/0249/24 and LIFE Resistance.
Natural numerical network for drone data
Data type: docx