Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Lucia Antonietta Santoianni ( lucia.santoianni@unimol.it ) Academic editor: Denys Vynokurov
© 2026 Marco Varricchione, Maria Laura Carranza, Dario Ciaramella, Sandra Citterio, Maria Carla de Francesco, Chiara Montagnani, Lucia Antonietta Santoianni, Angela Stanisci.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Varricchione M, Carranza ML, Ciaramella D, Citterio S, de Francesco MC, Montagnani C, Santoianni LA, Stanisci A (2026) Planting roots: distribution pattern of invasive alien plants in urban habitats of Campobasso (Italy). Vegetation Ecology and Diversity 63: e182200. https://doi.org/10.3897/ved.182200
|
Identifying the most widespread or potentially Invasive Alien Plant species (IAPs) and understanding their distribution patterns across urban environments is essential for developing effective management strategies and mitigating their impacts on urban, peri-urban, and natural habitats. This study examines the occurrence and spatial distribution of a set of IAPs along an urbanization gradient and across EUNIS Habitats in a Mediterranean city of Southern Italy (Campobasso). The study was carried out across 14 urban grid cells (500 m × 500 m) reflecting different levels of urbanization. 26 IAP species were surveyed according to a national standardized protocol; for each record, GPS coordinates, cultivated versus spontaneous status, EUNIS Habitat type, and cover area were recorded. The influence of urbanization on IAP richness and occurrence was assessed using Mann–Whitney tests. For species with predominantly spontaneous occurrences (>80%), we analyzed their distribution across EUNIS Habitats and cover area classes.
Grid cells with high cover and patch number of artificial surfaces were associated with significantly greater IAP richness and occurrence values. Slightly more than half of the total records consisted of spontaneously established individuals or populations belonging to ten species, with Senecio inaequidens, Robinia pseudoacacia, and Ailanthus altissima being the most frequent. Transport networks and other hard-surface constructed areas, followed by dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation, emerged as the most invaded habitat types. Overall, the findings highlight the need for early detection and prevention efforts targeting “emerging” invasive species that, although currently infrequent, may possess high potential for future expansion.
Ailanthus altissima, alien plants, early warning, EUNIS habitats, invasive plants, Senecio inaequidens, urban ecosystems, urbanization gradient
Cities act as hotspots for alien species (
Urban environments contain a broad range of micro-habitats, shelters, and ecological niches, that allow many alien plant species to establish and grow (
IAPs may cause a decrease of native biodiversity in cities and directly affect citizens’ health and daily activities, contributing to issues such as allergies, higher fire risk, and damage to infrastructure and cultural heritage (
IAPs may spread from urban to peri-urban, rural, and natural areas (
In cities where the interface between urban, rural, and semi-natural areas is particularly narrow, the probability of IAPs spreading from urban environments into natural habitats increases.
Moreover, the restoration and expansion of green areas and infrastructures may enhance the biological permeability of cities, thereby facilitating the dispersal of alien species (
The compilation of inventories that include ecological information on urban green spaces provides valuable insights into ornamental species that are currently invasive or have a high invasion potential, thus enabling prevention measures and targeted interventions (
Identifying the most widespread or potential Invasive Alien Plants and their urban distribution patterns is therefore essential to address management strategies and reduce their impacts in urban and natural habitats (
For assessing alien plant distribution in urban habitats, the application of the EUNIS Habitat classification system (
A local, but also national and European, strategy is indeed required to the prioritization process and to mitigate the impact of IAPs (
In this context, the present study aims to investigate the occurrence and distribution of a pool of 26 IAPs along the urbanization gradient and across urban EUNIS Habitats in a Mediterranean city of Southern Italy (Campobasso). Target species were selected by
Moreover, the findings seek to inform effective prevention strategies to mitigate the growing challenge of alien plant invasions.
The study was carried out in Campobasso, a Mediterranean city in Southern Italy (Fig.
Study area (Campobasso municipality) along with the grid cell types, classified across the urbanization gradient (A) and the first-level EUNIS Habitats (B); HH: high cover (>50%) and high patch number (≥ 20) of artificial surfaces; HM: high cover (>50%) and medium patch number (5 < x < 20) of artificial surfaces; MM: medium-low cover (<50%) with medium patch number (5 < x < 20) of artificial surfaces; ML: medium-low cover (<50%) with low patch number (≤5) of artificial surfaces; J: Constructed, industrial, and other artificial habitats; R: Grasslands and lands dominated by forbs, mosses, or lichens; S: Heathland, scrub, and tundra; T: Forest and other wooded land; U: Inland habitats with no or little soil and mostly with sparse vegetation; V: Vegetated man-made habitats. Red points refer to the occurrences of the target Invasive Alien Plant species recorded during the sampling activities.
In the study area, vegetated man-made habitats (56.8%, EUNIS Habitat V), mainly represented by mixed crops of market gardens and horticulture (11%, V12), large-scale ornamental garden areas (3%, V21), and dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation (1.6%, V38), prevail (
Alien species sampling followed the national protocol defined by
Surveys were conducted within fourteen 500 m × 500 m grid cells representing an urbanization gradient, chosen by random stratified method and based on the accessibility.
Each grid cell was classified into urbanization categories based on the composition (proportional cover) and spatial configuration (patch number) of artificial surfaces within the entire cell area. Both composition and configuration were classified into three levels (H: High, M: Medium, L: Low). This standardized approach allowed the identification of cells referable to four main urbanization categories in the analyzed city:
Field surveys were carried out during the autumn season, as it corresponds to the main blooming period of most IAPs (
In each grid cell, a team of botanists (from 2 to 4) surveyed all accessible areas and recorded every occurrence of the target species.
For each occurrence record, we collected the geographic coordinates (GPS), noted the local status (i.e., whether the individual/population occurred exclusively under cultivation or also in the wild), the EUNIS Habitat type (
List of EUNIS Habitats present in the 14 grid cells in Campobasso, along with their code, name, and description (EEA 2025).
| EUNIS Habitat | ||
|---|---|---|
| Code | Name | Description |
| J1 | Buildings of cities, towns, and villages | Buildings in built-up areas where buildings, roads, and other impermeable surfaces occupy at least 30% of the land. Includes agricultural building complexes where the built area exceeds 1 ha. |
| J4 | Transport networks and other constructed hard-surface areas | Includes roads, car parks, railways, paved footpaths, and hard-surfaced areas of airports, water ports, and recreational areas. |
| R | Grasslands and lands dominated by forbs, mosses, or lichens | Non-coastal land which is dry or only seasonally wet (with the water table at or above ground level for less than half of the year) with greater than 30% vegetation cover. The vegetation is dominated by grasses and other non-woody plants, including mosses, macrolichens, ferns, sedges, and herbs. Includes semiarid steppes with scattered Artemisia scrub. Includes successional weedy vegetation. |
| S | Heathland, scrub, and tundra | Non-coastal land which is dry or only seasonally inundated (with the water table at or above ground level for less than half of the year), usually with greater than 30% vegetation cover and with the development of soil. |
| T1J | Deciduous self-sown forest of non site-native trees | Non-planted stands dominated by non-native deciduous tree species such as Acer negundo, Ailanthus altissima, and Robinia pseudoacacia. |
| U | Inland habitats with no or little soil and mostly with sparse vegetation | Non-coastal habitats on substrates with no or little development of soil, mostly with less than 30% vegetation cover which are dry or only seasonally wet (with the water table at or above ground level for less than half of the year). Habitats which may have a high vegetation cover include crevices of rocks, screes or cliffs, and habitats formed by carpets of moss. |
| V12 | Mixed crops of market gardens and horticulture | Intensive cultivation of vegetables, flowers, and small fruits, usually in alternating strips of different crops. Includes allotments and small-scale market gardens. |
| V21 | Large-scale ornamental garden areas | Cultivated areas of large-scale recreational gardens. The vegetation, usually composed mainly of introduced species or cultivars, can nevertheless include many native plants and supports a varied fauna when not intensively managed. |
| V211 | Park flower beds, arbours, and shrubbery | Plantations of ornamental forbs or shrubs constituting elements of urban parks. |
| V22 | Small-scale ornamental and domestic garden areas | Cultivated areas of ornamental gardens and small parks beside houses or in city squares. Kitchen gardens in the immediate vicinity of dwelling places. |
| V38 | Dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation | Stands dominated by perennial herbaceous plants, frequently ruderals, developing on dry abandoned urban or agricultural land, on land that has been reclaimed, on transport networks, or on land used for waste disposal. These stands often replace annual anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation in the course of secondary succession. |
| V63 | Lines of planted trees | More or less continuous lines of trees forming strips within a matrix of grassy or cultivated land or along roads, typically used for shelter or shading. |
The EUNIS habitat classification was derived from the Nature Map of Campobasso (
During field surveys, to avoid oversampling, we distinguished occurrences based on the distance between presence cores (adjusted to species-specific dispersal and propagation strategies) and on the type of colonized environment (
We systematically classified all recorded IAPs based on taxonomic family, growth forms, geographic origin (
Moreover, to assess the potential influence of the urbanization gradient on IAP presence, we compared species richness and the number of occurrences across categories of the grid cells based on the composition and spatial configuration of artificial surfaces. Comparisons were conducted for all target IAPs occurrence records, as well as for spontaneous individuals/populations only. Significant differences among categories were evaluated using the Mann-Whitney pairwise post hoc tests for equal medians, with no correction for multiple comparisons.
Finally, we focused on the records occurring as spontaneous individuals/populations of target IAPs. We selected the IAPs with the highest occurrences of spontaneous individuals/populations (defined as those exceeding 80% of total spontaneous occurrences). For these species, to provide insights into potential ecological preferences or suitable conditions for their proliferation in specific urban contexts, we assessed their occurrences across the different EUNIS Habitats and their corresponding cover area classes.
Statistical analyses were performed in the R Statistical Software (v4.4.2,
Our results revealed the presence in the city of Campobasso of 14 of the target 26 urban IAPs, belonging to 11 taxonomic families. Asteraceae family accounts for 28.6% of the total IAPs. The majority of the registered IAPs come from temperate Asia and Northern America (Table
List of target Invasive Alien Plants registered in Campobasso city, along with the taxonomic family, growth form, origin area (
| Species | Taxonomic family | Growth form | Origin | Status in Italy | Status in Molise | Total occurrences (%) | Cultivated occurrences (%) | Spontaneous occurrences (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Acer negundo | Sapindaceae | P scap | Northern America | N INV | N CAS | 2% | 100 | 0 |
| Ailanthus altissima | Simaroubaceae | P scap | Asia-Temperate | N INV | N INV | 11% | 5.6 | 94.4 |
| Artemisia annua | Asteraceae | T scap | Africa, Asia-Temperate, Asia-Tropical | N INV | N NAT | <1% | 0 | 100 |
| Buddleja davidii | Scrophulariaceae | P caesp | Asia-Temperate | N INV | N/A | <1% | 33.3 | 66.7 |
| Helianthus tuberosus | Asteraceae | G rhiz | Northern America | N INV | N INV | 2% | 15.4 | 84.6 |
| Ligustrum lucidum | Oleaceae | P scap | Asia-Temperate, Asia-Tropical | N INV | N CAS | 7% | 95.5 | 4.6 |
| Lonicera japonica | Caprifoliaceae | P lian | Asia-Temperate | N INV | N/A | 1% | 40 | 60 |
| Parthenocissus spp. | Vitaceae | P lian | Northern America | N INV | N/A | 6% | 55 | 45 |
| Paulownia tomentosa | Paulowniaceae | P scap | Asia-Temperate | N INV | N/A | <1% | 100 | 0 |
| Prunus laurocerasus | Rosaceae | P caesp | Africa, Asia-Temperate, Europe | N INV | N/A | 25% | 98.1 | 1.9 |
| Quercus rubra | Fagaceae | P scap | Northern America | N INV | N/A | 1% | 100 | 0 |
| Robinia pseudoacacia | Fabaceae | P scap | Northern America | N INV | N INV | 16% | 20.2 | 79.8 |
| Senecio inaequidens | Asteraceae | Ch suffr | Southern Africa | N INV | N INV | 23% | 0 | 100 |
| Trachycarpus fortunei | Arecaceae | P scap | Asia-Temperate, Asia-Tropical | N INV | N/A | 5% | 100 | 0 |
All the recorded species are classified as invasive neophytes (N INV) at national level in Italy. However, only 4 (Ailanthus altissima, Helianthus tuberosus, Robinia pseudoacacia, and Senecio inaequidens) are considered N INV in Molise region (
Out of the 634 occurrences of target IAPs, the most frequently observed was Prunus laurocerasus (25%, primarily cultivated), followed by Senecio inaequidens (23%, entirely spontaneous), Robinia pseudoacacia (16%, mainly spontaneous), and Ailanthus altissima (11%, mainly spontaneous) (Table
The species richness and occurrence of the investigated pool of IAPs varied along the urbanization gradient. Specifically, grid cells characterized by a high cover and patch number of artificial surfaces (HH and HM) showed significantly higher values of IAP richness (9 vs. 4 species on average, p-value = 0.03) and occurrences (67 vs. 16 on average, p-value = 0.04) compared to grid cells with low cover and patch number of artificial areas (MM and ML; Fig.
Boxplots comparing richness and number of occurrences of the total recorded target Invasive Alien Plant (IAPs) species (A), of cultivated individuals/populations of target IAPs (B), and of spontaneous individuals/populations of target IAPs (C) across the urbanization gradient (HH: high cover (>50%) and high patch number (≥20) of artificial surfaces; HM: high cover (>50%) and medium patch number (5 < x < 20) of artificial surfaces; MM: medium-low cover (<50%) with medium patch number (5 < x < 20) of artificial surfaces; ML: medium-low cover (<50%) with low patch number (≤5) of artificial surfaces). Letters indicate significant differences according to the Mann-Whitney pairwise posthoc tests.
With regard to the distribution of occurrences of the selected IAPs across EUNIS Habitats, 33.9% are associated with small-scale ornamental and domestic garden areas (V22), 20.5% with dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation (V38), 20.3% with transport networks and other constructed hard-surface areas (J4), and 11.3% with large-scale ornamental garden areas (V21) (Suppl. material
Slightly more than half of the total occurrences of target IAPs (334) consisted of spontaneously established individuals/populations belonging to 10 species. Among these, the majority (>80% of the occurrences) were accounted for Senecio inaequidens (44%), Robinia pseudoacacia (23.7%), and Ailanthus altissima (20.1%) (Fig.
Percentage occurrences of spontaneously established individuals/populations of the target Invasive Alien Plant species recorded in Campobasso (Italy), calculated as the proportion of each species’ occurrences relative to the total occurrences of all recorded spontaneous individuals/populations.
Senecio inaequidens was primarily recorded along the transport networks and other constructed hard-surface areas (J4), followed by the dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation (V38). As an herbaceous species, it generally occurred in small areas, often as single individual or small individual groups (Fig.
Robinia pseudoacacia mainly occurred in V38, where it occupied large areas and formed dense patches composed of numerous individuals/populations, including mature trees (Fig.
Ailanthus altissima, by contrast, was more frequent in V38, where it mainly occupied large areas, typically forming small but dense patches. It also occurred in J4, in small areas, and was often represented by isolated or young individuals/populations growing in sidewalk cracks or along road edges (Fig.
The findings yield novel insights into how a suite of IAPs is distributed along the urbanization gradient and across EUNIS habitat types in a Mediterranean city.
The target IAPs recorded in Campobasso are mainly woody perennial species, used as ornamental species (
Among the target IAPs, the Asteraceae family prevails, in line with the overall composition of non-native flora in Italy (
This notable prevalence of American species may indicate a long-standing history of trade and interaction across multiple geographical regions over several centuries (
For half of the recorded species, the invasion status in Molise region is currently not available (N/A) (
Based on the analysis of the urbanization gradient, we observed that the most urbanized grid cells have higher richness and occurrences of target IAPs, as recorded in other cities (
Among the target IAPs species spontaneously established, the highest occurrences were accounted by Senecio inaequidens (44%), followed by Robinia pseudoacacia (23%), and Ailanthus altissima (20.1%). These findings partially align with previous records from Milan, Turin, and Rome, where the most widespread and frequent spontaneous species were Ailanthus altissima, Sorghum halepense, Phytolacca americana, and Robinia pseudoacacia (
Regarding the distribution of target IAPs across EUNIS Habitats in the study area, individuals/populations found in cultivation are associated with small-scale ornamental and domestic garden areas (V22) and large-scale ornamental garden areas (V21) (Suppl. material
In contrast, the pool of IAPs spontaneously established are mainly associated with dry perennial anthropogenic herbaceous vegetation (V38), found in abandoned areas within the city, and with transport networks and other constructed hard-surface areas (J4). These are the primary colonization sites for Invasive Alien Plants in urban environments, as they offer space, resources, and low native species cover (
Analysing which EUNIS Habitats hosted the most abundant spontaneously growing IAPs (Senecio inaequidens, Robinia pseudoacacia, Ailanthus altissima), it can be noted that the most widespread one, the South African Senecio inaequidens, mainly occurred in J4, as also documented in other studies (
The edges of roads and railway lines represent the ecological corridor that allows rapid dispersal of IAPs both in urban environments and in more natural areas (
As regards Robinia pseudoacacia and Ailanthus altissima, they are mostly related to V38, corresponding to the vegetation stage with pioneer trees of secondary succession developing on dry abandoned urban or agricultural land or on land with man-made ground. This finding was also observed for Milan, Turin, and Rome (
Robinia pseudoacacia forms wooded patches in degraded and vacant urban lots, and it does not seem to threaten urban habitats of conservation relevance. Furthermore, it has a fundamental role in allowing the natural greening of urban areas with degraded, nitrate-rich soil, where native tree species fail to take root (
Ailanthus altissima is also abundant in J4, colonizing side slopes along roads and railways. This habitat serves as a natural corridor facilitating the species’ dispersal and allowing swift movement both into and out of the city, as reported by
Roads are also the gateway for this IAP towards protected areas, as documented by the research made by the Mountain Invasion Research Network (MIREN) (
Ailanthus altissima is a species of Union relevance (
Its occurrence in Central Apennine is high in areas where potential natural vegetation has been destroyed by humans, in afforestation, and where there is a recurrent anthropogenic disturbance that alters the soil (
However, further investigations are needed to better understand its dynamics and ecology in Italian natural contexts. The participative science project AilantItaly was recently launched address to these issues (
For management and prevention purposes, the containment of Senecio inaequidens, Robinia pseudoacacia, and Ailanthus altissima, now widespread both in urban and rural landscapes, appears prohibitive in economic terms (
In the urban context, eradication/containment efforts should be addressed for the conservation of monumental or sacred sites, where several IAPs cause important damages (
Still, it could be useful to invest in preventing the spread of “emerging” invasive or potentially invasive species that we have documented to be present at low frequencies in natural environments, but that could have the potential for expansion in the coming decades. In particular, on species that are currently casual neophytes in the study region, but which could become invasive in the coming years, as has already happened in other Italian regions (
In detail, Buddleja davidii, Helianthus tuberosus, Parthenocissus spp., Lonicera japonica, Acer negundo, and Quercus rubra could spread to riparian and riverbed habitats, as well as floodplains, as has been observed in other Italian and European areas (
The early warning for these taxa should be shared with key stakeholders such as nursery companies, urban architects, agronomists-forestry, citizens, schools, and technical offices of local authorities (
One limitation of the present study is the pre-selection of a nationally defined list of 26 invasive alien species, which resulted in the exclusion of other invasive alien species occurring in the study area. This approach was adopted to ensure a standardized sampling framework and to keep sampling effort manageable, particularly in large urban areas such as Milan, Rome, and Turin (
Results highlight that, even in inland and medium-small cities, the pool of investigated IAPs occurs and is either invasive or potentially invasive. The prevalence of occurrences in roadside habitats and urban abandoned areas, together with the close interface between urban, rural, and semi-natural environments, makes the landscape potentially permeable to the spread of these IAPs and may facilitate the outward dispersal of these species from the city toward areas of higher naturalness.
In the examined area, the South African Senecio inaequidens emerged as the most prevalent and spontaneously established IAP; this species can be harmful in hill and mountain pastures, especially in a region where livestock farming is still widespread and oriented toward high-quality dairy production.
These findings underscore the importance of preventing the spread of the studied IAPs into natural and semi-natural environments and into the surrounding of Natura 2000 sites, both near the city and across the region, through stakeholder engagement, periodic monitoring, and targeted containment or eradication measures aimed at safeguarding conservation-relevant habitats and grazed or mowed grasslands.
The use of the EUNIS classification can enhance the comparability of data on invaded urban and natural habitats, facilitating comparative analyses across biogeographical regions and cities of different sizes, thereby enabling the identification of common, and consequently more effective, guidelines for the monitoring, prevention, and management of IAPs.
Conflict of interest
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Ethical statement
No ethical statement was reported.
Use of AI
ChatGPT (OpenAI) was used for English language editing and linguistic revision of the manuscript.
Funding
The work is funded under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan (NRRP), Mission 4 Component 2 Investment 1.4 – Call for tender No. 3138 of 16 December 2021, rectified by Decree n.3175 of 18 December 2021 of Italian Ministry of University and Research funded by the European Union – NextGenerationEU; Project code CN_00000033, Concession Decree No. 1034 of 17 June 2022 adopted by the Italian Ministry of University and Research, CUP H73C22000300001, Hub: Biodiversity, Spoke 5: Urban biodiversity, Project title “National Biodiversity Future Center – NBFC”, and by the project PRIN 2022JBP5F8-PREVALIEN, Enhancing Knowledge on Prevention and Early Detection of the Invasive Alien Plants of (European) Union concern in the Italian Protected Areas, CUP Master: J53D2300657-0006.
Author contributions
Marco Varricchione: Conceptualization, Data Curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Validation, Visualization, Writing – Original Draft, Writing – Review & Editing. Maria Laura Carranza: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Project administration, Writing – Review & Editing. Dario Ciaramella: Data curation, Investigation, Writing – Review & Editing. Sandra Citterio: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Project administration, Writing – Review & Editing. Maria Carla de Francesco: Data curation, Investigation, Writing – Review & Editing. Chiara Montagnani: Conceptualization, Funding acquisition, Methodology, Project administration, Writing – Review & Editing. Lucia Antonietta Santoianni: Data Curation, Formal analysis, Investigation, Validation, Writing – Original Draft, Writing – Review & Editing. Angela Stanisci: Conceptualization, Data curation, Funding acquisition, Project administration, Supervision, Validation, Writing – Original Draft, Writing – Review & Editing.
Author ORCIDs
Marco Varricchione https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4716-6609
Maria Laura Carranza https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5753-890X
Dario Ciaramella https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3646-0546
Sandra Citterio https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5020-1095
Maria Carla de Francesco https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5238-1154
Chiara Montagnani https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2030-2535
Lucia Antonietta Santoianni https://orcid.org/0009-0008-3486-0769
Angela Stanisci https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5302-0932
Data availability
The data underlying this study are available from the corresponding author upon request.
List of the 26 target Invasive Alien Plants species
Data type: docx
Explanation note: List of the 26 target Invasive Alien Plants species (IAPs) along with the taxonomic family and growth form.
Percentage of the occurrences of recorded target Invasive Alien Species
Data type: docx
Explanation note: Percentage of the occurrences of recorded target Invasive Alien Plant species (IAPs) and of only cultivated and spontaneous individual/population in each EUNIS Habitats (
Coverage (km2) of first-level EUNIS habitats and Coverage (%) of first-level EUNIS habitats
Data type: docx
Explanation note: Coverage (km2) of first-level EUNIS habitats (
Distribution maps of the most frequent Invasive Alien Species
Data type: docx
Explanation note: Distribution maps of the most frequent Invasive Alien Plant species (IAPs) found in Campobasso (Ailanthus altissima, Prunus laurocerasus, Robinia pseudoacacia, and Senecio inaequidens) in the four grid cell types.